Opinion | How Modi convincingly demolished the costs levelled by his critics

Picture Supply : INDIA TV

Opinion | How Modi convincingly demolished the costs levelled by his critics

Prime Minister Narendra Modi on Monday replied to a lot of the questions raised by the opposition on the problem of latest farm legal guidelines. He additionally nailed the lies that have been being unfold within the title of farmers’ agitation for the final a number of weeks.

Questions had been raised by his critics on whether or not minimal help costs (MSP) and agricultural ‘mandis’ can be abolished, on whether or not industrialists would achieve an higher hand if contract farming was allowed, on whether or not small and marginal farmers might be utterly marginalized, on whether or not farmers will lose possession of their land and develop into slaves of industrialists, and comparable different questions.

Questions had been raised on why farmers have been sitting on dharna for the final 75 days if the legal guidelines have been useful for them, on who’re the forces who don’t want the farmers and the federal government to achieve a compromise, on why India’s title is being tarnished if the legal guidelines are pro-farmer. There have been questions on why Sikhs and Jat farmers have been sad with the PM, on whether or not the federal government’s stand was tyrannical.

Prime Minister Modi had been holding an in depth eye on all these questions, and on Monday in Rajya Sabha, he got here out along with his replies. He raised questions on those that have been pointing fingers at his pro-farmer bonafide.

The Prime Minister emphatically stated (1) MSP was there, MSP is right here and MSP will stay in future (2) the distribution of low cost foodgrains to the poor via Public Distribution System will proceed (three) the worry that industrial homes will seize the land of farmers was primarily based on lies.

Citing an instance, Modi identified how farmers have been promoting milk to corporates for the final a number of many years. He stated, they have been free to promote milk anyplace in India, and dairy farming constituted 28 per cent of agricultural sector. In a rhetorical flourish, Modi requested, has there been any case the place a businessman forcibly took away the buffaloes of a farmer? Equally, the farmers needn’t worry about their land, if they begin contract farming for corporates.

Modi stated, the brand new legal guidelines may even profit the small and marginal farmers, who represent 68 per cent of the farming group and personal lower than 2 hectares of land. Is it not my authorities’s responsibility to assist the small farmers?, he requested.

Since a bulk of the protesters are Sikh farmers from Punjab, Modi sought to reject the costs being levelled by Khalistan supporters that his authorities was anti-Sikh. He stated, the nation is happy with the courageous Sikh group and Sikhs have set shining examples within the fields of humanitarian service and defence.

Since each the Congress and the Left are supporting the farmers’ agitation, Modi focused the Left and reminded what the Left events had finished when Lal Bahadur Shastri was Prime Minister. Shastriji, he stated, needed to usher in Inexperienced Revolution in India, however the Left events opposed him and labelled Shastriji as “an American agent”. They’re doing the identical factor now, Modi stated.

The Left frontal organizations are already energetic within the farmers’ motion in Rajasthan, Punjab, Maharashtra and Madhya Pradesh. The ‘tukde tukde’ gangs, which have been energetic throughout the Shaheen Bagh, JNU and Jamia Millia agitations, are actually energetic within the farmers’ stir. On Monday, Modi named these individuals as ‘andolanjeevi’ (skilled protesters) and requested individuals to be on guard towards such components who consider in FDI(international damaging ideology).

After protesters induced mayhem with tractors and insulted the nationwide flag at Pink Fort on Republic Day, police needed to arrange barricades with concertina wires and cemented nails. Photographs of those barricades have been circulated the world over to defame India. A improper notion about “atrocities on farmers and dissenters” is being created with the allegation Modi is “crushing democracy”.

The Prime Minister replied to those fees by quoting Netaji Subhash Chandra Bose. He stated, India was not solely the world’s most populous democracy however is the “mom of democracies”. In India, democracy shouldn’t be solely a system,  however it’s  additionally part of way of life and ethos of the Indian individuals, Modi stated.

General, Modi, via his convincing replies, laced with sarcasm, answered a lot of the questions that have been raised by the opposition and farmer leaders in latest weeks. However no one may also help, if the opposite aspect is unwilling to hearken to cause.

I’m shocked when some individuals allege that the farmers’ agitation was mishandled. These embrace a few of Modi’s supporters who stated the problem may have been dealt with in a greater method.

My questions are:  If Modi’s ministers mentioned the problem with farmer leaders 11 occasions, was it mishandling? Even on Monday, Modi stated the street for talks remains to be open. Is it mishandling, if Modi guarantees no abolition of MSP and ‘mandis? Will you name it mishandling if Modi provides to amend the farm legal guidelines if required? Was it mishandling to supply the farmers 18 months to offer the farm legal guidelines a trial? Was it mishandling when Modi advised farmers to not consider in rumour and rumours and undergo the high quality print within the farm legal guidelines?

Was it mishandling to inform police to not fireplace a single bullet at protesters? Was it mishandling when greater than 300 policemen have been injured and the police didn’t use drive when the nationwide flag was being insulted at Pink Fort? Was it mishandling when Modi recalled the nice sacrifices by Sikh gurus and leaders when lies have been being propagated concerning the authorities being anti-Sikh?

I’ve watched historical past unfolding in entrance of my very own eyes. It was grave mishandling when a number of thousand Sikhs have been killed in Delhi throughout 1984 after Indira Gandhi’s assassination. It was mishandling when Delhi police in a midnight swoop on Swami Ramdev’s dharna, lathicharged his supporters  on June 5, 2011, after they have been sleeping. Blood of harmless individuals have been shed.

The shocking half is that each different concern is being raised in reference to a farmers’ agitation besides their core points regarding farm legal guidelines. Questions are being raised about why cemented iron spikes and concertina wire have been positioned to dam highways. Questions are being raised about why farmers are being labelled as Khalistanis. Questions are being raised on why a handful of individuals have been allowed to enter Pink Fort and insult the nationwide flag. Questions are being raised on why Modi used the phrase ‘jamaat’ for farmers.

Right here too, the shocking half is that the farmers themselves are usually not elevating these questions.  The moot level is that some individuals with vested pursuits inimical to India, are utilizing the farmers’ agitation to sully the nation’s picture within the worldwide area. They’re those that are levelling baseless allegations that democracy and open dissent are being crushed throughout Modi’s rule. It’s for the individuals of India to determine who’s talking the reality.


Aaj Ki Baat: Monday to Friday, 9 PM

India’s Quantity One and essentially the most adopted Tremendous Prime Time Information Present ‘Aaj Ki Baat – Rajat Sharma Ke Saath was launched simply earlier than the 2014 Basic Elections. Since its inception, the present is redefining India’s super-prime time and is numerically far forward of its contemporaries.

Newest India Information

Please follow and like us:

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *